Incredible vs Strong: Do You Need a Separate App for Gym Logging?
Strong is a polished gym log with a free tier and Strong PRO from $4.99 a month. Incredible is a free gym log that counts your sets in a daily Readiness score, and it imports your Strong routines and history.
Incredible is a free app for iPhone and Apple Watch with a full strength tracker, a daily Readiness score, Fitness and vitals. Strong is a dedicated gym log with clean exercise logging and progression tools. Both log your lifts well. Incredible also counts those sets in the score you see each morning, beside your sleep and overnight readings, without telling you what to do.
At a Glance
| Feature | Incredible | Strong |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | Free (3 custom routines), Strong PRO $4.99 a month, $29.99 a year or $99.99 once |
| Strength training logging | Yes | Yes |
| Exercise library | Yes, with a page for every exercise | Yes, with animated videos |
| Apple Watch app | Yes, and it works with your iPhone out of reach | Yes, with or without your iPhone |
| Routines | Yes | Yes (3 on the free version) |
| Supersets | Yes, and circuits | Yes |
| Rest timers and warm-up sets | Yes | Yes, plus a warm-up calculator and a plate calculator |
| Daily score | Readiness, 0 to 100 | None in its feature list |
| Muscle Freshness | Yes, muscle by muscle | None in its feature list |
| HRV, sleep and vitals | Yes | Body measurements only |
| Fitness | Built from all your recorded training | Volume and 1RM progression per exercise |
| AI coach | Free, off until you turn it on | None in its feature list |
| Platforms | iPhone and Apple Watch | iPhone, Android and Apple Watch |
| Sync and backup | Your own iCloud | Strong's Cloud Sync |
The Core Difference
Strong is a gym log. It tracks sets, reps and weight, and it does that well. The interface is clean, it has warm-up and plate calculators, set tags for warm-ups, failure and drop sets, supersets, rest timers, and an Apple Watch app that logs with or without your iPhone. For years it has been a default recommendation for anyone who wants a no-nonsense lifting tracker.
What Strong's feature list does not include is sleep, HRV or a daily score. Your training log and your overnight readings stay in separate apps.
Incredible logs the same sets and then counts them. Its Readiness score is built from your sleep, your overnight measurements, and the cost of today's training, movement and daytime stress, each against your own usual range. A logged lift lowers it by its sets and weights, not only by its heart rate.
Strength Training
Both apps handle the fundamentals: an exercise library, set, rep and weight logging, routines and history.
Strong has mature pure-logging features: supersets, an auto rest timer, a warm-up calculator, a plate calculator, set tags, notes and progress pictures, and graphs for volume and 1RM progression. Its Apple Watch app logs a whole session without your phone, and Cloud Sync backs up your data.
Incredible covers the same core: an exercise library, set by set logging on iPhone or Apple Watch, rest timers, warm-up sets, supersets and circuits, saved routines, and a page for every exercise with your records and progress. You can start a routine on your Apple Watch with your iPhone out of reach, and your sets reach the phone when it's back. Logged sets feed Training Load, Readiness and Fitness.
If you're switching, Import Routines reads a Strong export and brings in your routines and your workout history with its sets. It reads Hevy and Fitbod exports too, or you can send the coach a screenshot and it builds the routine for you.
If you rely on a plate calculator or Strong's set tags and progress pictures, Strong has the edge in pure logging depth. If you want your gym data connected to sleep, vitals and Fitness, Incredible has the edge. Strong is also the choice if you need Android.
Training Context and Recovery
Strong lists no recovery, sleep or HRV features. It does keep body measurements, with Apple Health support. To get a recovery score, Strong users typically run a second app, such as WHOOP or Athlytic, and compare the two in their head.
That two-app setup has a gap: the recovery app doesn't see your sets, and the gym log doesn't see your sleep. You're left to connect "my HRV is low" with "I squatted heavy yesterday" yourself.
Incredible brings both into one score. Sleep matters most, and HRV, resting heart rate, body temperature and respiratory rate make up the rest. Today's training is the biggest cost during the day, and it costs more after several hard days. The score page shows what helped readiness and what lowered it, and the label reads Recover below 50, Pace Yourself from 50, Ready from 75 and Go For It from 90.
Muscle Freshness goes one step further. From your logged sets and your cardio, it shows which muscles are ready to train and which still need rest, against your own usual. It is an estimate from your training log, not a measurement of the muscle, and the decision stays yours.
If you keep logging in another app, Incredible still sees those workouts through Apple Health, but with heart rate only. After three lifts like that in six weeks, it suggests logging the next one in Incredible so every set counts in Muscle Freshness and Muscular Load.
Apple Watch Series 12 and Ultra 4 now have Apple's own readiness score as well. Incredible gives you a daily Readiness score on older watches too, free on Series 4 and later. The score shows on the watch itself from Series 6, which runs watchOS 11. Check what your watch gets.
Fitness Level Tracking
Incredible has Fitness, a 0 to 100 score built from all your recorded training, cardio and strength together. It is a slow average, so recent weeks count most and months of history still count. Training Balance compares your recent week with that base; it does not predict injury or overtraining. Muscular Load and Cardio Load show the week's load on your muscles and on your heart against your usual week.
Strong tracks per-exercise progress: volume, personal records, estimated one rep max and total weight lifted. You can see your bench press trend over six months, and it does that well. Its feature list doesn't combine those sessions with your cardio into one measure of your training load.
Vitals
Incredible shows HRV, resting heart rate, body temperature, blood oxygen and respiratory rate with trend charts, plus a nightly sleep score. Blood oxygen is shown as its own vital and does not move Readiness.
Strong keeps body measurements such as weight, with Apple Health support. Its feature list has no HRV, sleep or resting heart rate. Your Apple Watch saves those to Apple Health every day, and Incredible reads them.
Pricing
Incredible is free, with no ads. Coach Pro is an optional subscription for those who want the most capable AI. The tip jar is optional. A tip of any size unlocks three extras: Customize your team, the gold app icon and extra widget designs. Inviting friends unlocks them too. Strength training, Readiness, Fitness, Muscle Freshness, the coach and the vitals are free. Get Incredible on the App Store.
Strong is free for unlimited workouts but limits you to 3 custom routines. Strong PRO costs $4.99 a month or $29.99 a year, and the App Store also lists Strong PRO Forever for $99.99. The one-time option is reasonable next to most subscriptions.
Here is where the math gets interesting. Many Strong users also pay for a recovery app, such as Athlytic at $29.99 a year or WHOOP from $199 a year, because Strong doesn't give them a morning score. A Strong-based setup can then cost $99.99 once plus $30 to $200 a year. Incredible's gym log and daily score together cost $0.
Privacy
Incredible works out every score on your iPhone and Apple Watch, and your workouts and health data stay there and in your own iCloud. There is no account to make; Sign in with Apple is optional. If you turn on the AI coach, your message and a summary of your training and health go to the AI service to write the reply, and nothing is kept on a server. Incredible never sells your data, never uses health data for ads, and does not track you.
Strong backs up your data with Cloud Sync. Its App Store privacy label lists health and fitness data, your email address and identifiers as collected and linked to you, for app functionality. That is a reasonable trade for backup across devices, but it means your training data lives on Strong's servers.
Who Should Choose What
Choose Incredible if you want a gym log and a daily score in one app, or you're tired of paying for a strength tracker while running a separate recovery app. It's free, your sets count in Readiness, and Import Routines brings your Strong routines and history with you.
Choose Strong if you want the most polished pure gym log, need Android, or rely on its plate calculator, set tags and progress pictures. If you already have a recovery app you're happy with, Strong remains one of the best at what it does, and the one-time PRO purchase is good value if you only need a log.
Strong is a great gym log. Incredible covers the same logging, supersets and Apple Watch sessions included, and then counts your sets in a daily Readiness score beside your sleep and vitals, with Fitness and Muscle Freshness on top. One free app, coaches included, and you can bring your Strong history with you.